Part 1

They said the horse was cursed. Thirty men had tried to break him, and thirty men had failed. Some walked away with broken bones; some never walked again.

I stood at the edge of the corral, clutching a small, battered suitcase that didn’t belong to me. The dust of the Montana plains coated my throat, but it was the fear that made it hard to swallow. Inside the fence stood Brimstone.

He was a nightmare carved from midnight shadows. His coat was black, his muscles tight as wire, and his eyes burned with a fury that dared the world to come closer. He struck the dirt with his hooves, a warning that echoed in the silence of the vast ranch.

The owner, Reed Coulter, stood beside me. He was the richest rancher for miles, a man built from hard years and silence. He didn’t look at me. He looked at the horse.

“He’s not for sale,” Reed said, his voice low and rough. “And neither is this ranch. If you think you can change things here, you’re wrong.”

I tightened my grip on the letter in my hand. The letter addressed to Emma.

“I didn’t come to change things,” I whispered, my voice trembling just enough to be real. “I came to survive.”

Reed finally turned to look at me. He expected a bride. He expected Emma, the woman who wrote to him promising to cook, clean, and stay out of his way.

But I wasn’t Emma. Emma was my sister. She d*ied in a cold room in Missouri two weeks ago. I was the one left with nothing but her trunk, her letter, and a desperate need to escape a past that was hunting me down.

I had stepped off the train with a lie on my lips. I looked at Reed, this stranger I was supposed to marry, and saw the same wall around his heart that I had built around mine.

“You’re smaller than I thought,” Reed said, studying my worn dress and the exhaustion etched under my eyes.

“I’m stronger than I look,” I lied. Or maybe I hoped.

That first night, the silence of the ranch was deafening. I lay in a spare room, listening to the wind howl. But then, I heard another sound. A high-pitched, terrified scream from the barn.

I ran out, barefoot in the dirt.

Brimstone had cornered a stable boy. The horse was rearing, teeth snapping, hooves flashing like lightning. Men were shouting, throwing ropes, their faces twisted in anger.

“Put him down!” someone yelled. “He’s a devil!”

“No!” I didn’t know where the voice came from. It tore out of my throat before I could stop it.

I ran toward the corral. Reed grabbed my arm, his grip like iron. “Don’t. He’ll k*ll you.”

I looked at the horse. I didn’t see a devil. I saw the whites of his eyes rolling in panic. I saw the way he trembled, not from rage, but from terror. I saw a creature that had been hurt so many times, he decided to hurt the world back before it could touch him again.

I looked at Reed, pulling my arm free. “He isn’t angry, Mr. Coulter. He’s terrified. And I know exactly what that feels like.”

I stepped toward the fence. The men went silent. Brimstone froze, his sides heaving, watching me.

I didn’t have a plan. I only had a secret that was eating me alive, and a feeling that if I couldn’t save this horse, I certainly couldn’t save myself.

The days on the ranch didn’t pass; they ground you down, like a pestle in a mortar, until you were nothing but dust and grit.

I woke before the sun every morning. The floorboards of the farmhouse were cold enough to sting my bare feet, a sharp reminder that I wasn’t dreaming. I wasn’t back in Missouri. I wasn’t in that small, suffocating room where my sister took her last breath. I was in Montana, living a lie that felt heavier with every sunrise.

My routine was a shield. If I kept moving, I didn’t have to think. I scrubbed floors until my knuckles were raw. I beat rugs until the dust choked the air. I cooked meals that Reed Coulter ate in silence, his eyes tracking me when he thought I wasn’t looking.

He didn’t trust me. I could feel it. He watched me the way a man watches a storm on the horizon—waiting to see if it will pass or if it will tear the roof off his house.

But the real work—the work that kept my heart beating—happened in the corral.

Every day, after the breakfast dishes were cleared and the house was silent, I walked out to where Brimstone waited. The men called him the Devil. They spat when they walked past his pen, making warding signs against bad luck. They laughed when they saw me, the “mail-order waif,” standing by the fence.

“Hey, darlin’,” one of the hands, a man named dusty, called out on the fourth day. “You gonna read him a bedtime story? Maybe knit him a sweater?”

Laughter rippled through the group. They were leaning against the barn, cigarettes dangling from their lips, watching the show. Watching for the moment the city girl got trampled.

I didn’t look at them. I kept my eyes on the black stallion pacing the perimeter of the dirt ring.

“Go away,” I whispered, not to the men, but to the fear in my own gut.

I slipped through the rails.

The change in the air was instant. Brimstone stopped pacing. His head snapped up, ears pinned back against his skull. He let out a snort that sounded like a steam engine releasing pressure. His muscles bunched, rippling under that obsidian coat. He was beautiful, and he was terrifying.

I didn’t bring a rope. I didn’t bring a whip. I didn’t even bring an apple. I brought myself, and the heavy, invisible sack of trauma I carried on my shoulders.

I walked to the center of the corral and sat down in the dirt.

The men went quiet. They expected me to chase him. They expected me to wave my arms. Sitting down? That was surrender. That was madness.

Brimstone watched me. He was waiting for the trick. He was waiting for the pain. In his world, humans only meant two things: pain or demand. I offered neither. I crossed my legs, dusted off my skirt, and started to hum.

It wasn’t a happy song. It was a low, mournful tune my mother used to sing when the nights were loud and the shouting downstairs got too bad. A song about a river that washed everything away.

Brimstone charged.

The ground shook. I felt the vibration travel up my spine. The dust cloud billowed as he thundered toward me, a thousand pounds of muscle and rage.

Don’t move, I told myself. If you move, you prove him right. If you move, you’re just prey.

I closed my eyes. The thunder got louder. The smell of horse sweat and dry earth filled my nose. Then—silence.

I opened my eyes. He had stopped ten feet away. His chest was heaving, his nostrils flared wide, revealing the red velvet inside. He was staring at me, confused. Why hadn’t I run? Why hadn’t I hit him?

“I see you,” I whispered.

He snorted and turned away, kicking up dirt as he trotted to the far side of the fence. But his ear was swivelled toward me. He was listening.

For two weeks, this was our dance. The men stopped laughing and started whispering. They called me a witch. They said I was casting spells.

Reed Coulter was the only one who didn’t whisper.

One evening, after a particularly grueling day where Brimstone had actually taken a step toward me before retreating, I was sitting on the back porch, nursing a cup of black coffee. My hands were shaking. They always shook after the corral. It was the adrenaline leaving my body.

The screen door creaked. Reed stepped out. He didn’t sit next to me—he respected boundaries, I’ll give him that—but he leaned against the railing, looking out at the purple and orange streaks of the sunset.

“You’re crazy,” he said. His voice wasn’t unkind, just factual. Like he was stating the weather.

I took a sip of coffee. “Probably.”

“Jake says you’re gonna get yourself k*lled. Says I should put a stop to it.”

My stomach tightened at the name. Jake. The foreman. A man with eyes like flint and a smile that never reached them. He hated me. I could feel his hatred like a heat source whenever I walked into the barn. He hated that I was in the house, he hated that I was “soft,” and he hated that I was doing something with Brimstone that he couldn’t.

“Jake thinks horses are machines,” I said, staring into my cup. “He thinks you put a coin in—pain—and you get a ticket out—obedience.”

Reed turned his head, studying my profile. “And what do you think?”

“I think Brimstone isn’t mean, Mr. Coulter. I think he’s heartbroken.”

Reed scoffed, a dry sound in his throat. “He’s an animal, Emma. He don’t have a heart like that.”

I flinched at the name. Emma. It felt like a stone in my shoe every time he said it. I looked up at him, and for a second, I let the mask slip. I let him see the exhaustion, the fear, the history written in the lines of my face.

“You think animals don’t feel betrayal?” I asked quietly. “You think they don’t remember when the hand that was supposed to feed them struck them instead? You think they don’t know what it’s like to be trapped in a box while someone stronger than them decides their fate?”

The silence that stretched between us was heavy. Reed looked at me—really looked at me—and his expression shifted. The hardness around his eyes softened, just a fraction. He saw something. Maybe he didn’t know what it was, but he recognized the language of damage.

“I fixed the loose shutter in your room,” he said abruptly, changing the subject. “Wind shouldn’t keep you up tonight.”

It was a small thing. A nothing thing. But to me, it felt like an earthquake. “Thank you,” I whispered.

He nodded, tipped his hat, and went back inside. I sat there until the coffee went cold, wondering how long I could keep pretending to be strong.

The breakthrough happened on a Tuesday.

The heat was oppressive, a dry blanket that smothered the ranch. The air was still, not a breath of wind to stir the dust. I was in the corral, sweat trickling down my back, singing a different song today. Something lighter.

Brimstone was closer than ever. He was circling me, tighter and tighter. Five feet. Four feet.

I didn’t look at him directly. Direct eye contact is a threat to a wild thing. I looked at his shoulder. I looked at his hooves.

He stopped directly behind me. I could feel his body heat radiating against my back. I could hear the wet intake of his breath.

My heart hammered against my ribs like a trapped bird. This was it. He could rear up and crush my skull with one strike. He could bite through my shoulder.

Trust him, a voice in my head said. He needs you to trust him first.

Slowly, agonizingly slowly, I raised my hand backward over my shoulder. Palm open. Fingers relaxed. An offering.

I waited.

A minute passed. Then two. My arm started to ache.

Then, I felt it.

Velvet. Hot, wet breath against my palm. Then the coarse whiskers. Then the solid weight of his muzzle resting in my hand.

A sob caught in my throat. I bit my lip to keep it silent. He was touching me. The beast that had broken thirty men, the “cursed” stallion, was resting his nose in the hand of a woman who was just as terrified as he was.

I turned my head slowly. His great dark eye was huge, liquid, and filled with a profound sadness.

“It’s okay,” I whispered, tears leaking from my eyes, cutting tracks through the dust on my face. “I’ve got you. No one is going to hurt you anymore. I promise.”

He let out a long sigh, his whole body shuddering as the tension left him.

From the fence, I heard a sound. A sharp intake of breath.

I looked up to see Reed standing there. He had stopped on his way to the fields. His hands were gripping the rail, his knuckles white. He was staring at us with an expression of pure shock.

But behind him, in the shadows of the barn, I saw something else.

Jake.

He was watching, too. But there was no wonder in his face. Only a dark, simmering rage. He spat into the dirt, turned on his heel, and disappeared into the darkness of the stable.

That night, the atmosphere in the bunkhouse must have been poisonous, because the next morning, the ranch felt wrong.

The air was too heavy. The chickens were silent. Even the wind seemed to hold its breath.

I went to the kitchen to start the coffee, my hands moving automatically. Reed was already at the table. That was unusual. He usually waited for the smell of bacon before coming down.

“You made progress yesterday,” he said, not looking up from his newspaper.

“He’s not a monster, Reed,” I said, using his first name for the first time without thinking. I froze, waiting for him to correct me.

He didn’t. He just folded the paper. “Jake’s not happy. Says you’re making the men look bad. Says a woman messing with a stallion is unnatural.”

“Jake is afraid,” I said, cracking an egg into the skillet. The hiss of the grease filled the silence. “He’s afraid that everything he knows about strength is wrong. He thinks strength is about breaking things. He doesn’t know that it takes a hell of a lot more strength to heal something.”

Reed looked at me then. His eyes were intense, blue and piercing. “And you? What are you healing from, Emma?”

The question hung in the air like smoke.

I gripped the spatula tight. “Everyone has a past, Mr. Coulter.”

“Most people don’t run halfway across the country to marry a stranger just to escape it,” he countered. “You scream in your sleep. Did you know that?”

My blood ran cold. “I…”

“You yell ‘No’. You yell ‘Don’t touch me’. And sometimes…” He paused, his voice dropping lower. “Sometimes you call out a name. And it ain’t mine.”

I turned off the stove. My appetite was gone. “I should go check on Brimstone.”

I fled the kitchen. I couldn’t tell him. If I told him I wasn’t Emma, if I told him I was the runaway sister, the damaged goods, he would send me back. And if I went back, I was dead.

I went straight to the corral, needing the comfort of the only creature who understood me without words.

But when I got there, something was wrong.

Brimstone was pacing frantically. He was sweating, his coat slick with foam. His eyes were rolling.

“Hey, hey,” I called out, climbing through the fence. “It’s me. It’s okay.”

He didn’t stop. He wheeled around, bucking at the air.

I looked around. The ground was disturbed near the water trough. I walked over, checking the dirt. There were boot prints. Heavy ones. And the water…

I dipped my finger in the trough. It smelled strange. Sharp. Like whiskey and something bitter.

My heart stopped. Someone had messed with his water. Someone was trying to make him crazy again.

“Hey!”

I spun around. Jake was leaning against the gate, a piece of straw in his teeth. He was smiling, but his eyes were dead.

“Horse looks a little spirited today,” he drawled.

“What did you do?” I demanded, my voice shaking with fury. “What did you put in his water?”

Jake laughed, pushing himself off the fence. He walked toward me. He was big, looming, and he smelled of tobacco and malice.

“Didn’t do nothin’, little lady. Maybe he’s just realizing who he is. He’s a killer. And you…” He stepped closer, invading my space. “You’re just a little girl playing pretend. You think you can tame a beast like that? You think you belong here?”

I stood my ground, though every instinct in my body screamed at me to run. This was my father. This was the man who raised his hand. This was the fear I had run a thousand miles to escape.

“Get out of my way, Jake,” I said, my voice low and dangerous.

He reached out and grabbed my arm. His fingers dug into my flesh, bruising. “You listen to me. You’re embarrassing Mr. Coulter. You’re making this ranch a laughing stock. If you know what’s good for you, you’ll pack that little bag of yours and get back on the train.”

Flashbacks hit me like a physical blow. The grip. The smell of stale sweat. The helplessness.

No. Not again.

“Let go,” I hissed.

“Or what?” Jake sneered.

Suddenly, a sound tore through the air. A scream. Not human.

Brimstone.

He charged.

Jake didn’t see him coming. He was too focused on bullying me. But I saw the black blur.

“Jake, move!” I shoved him. Not to save him, maybe, but to stop the slaughter.

Jake stumbled back, releasing me just as Brimstone slammed into the space where we had been standing. The horse didn’t strike. He stood there, placing himself between me and Jake. He lowered his head, ears pinned flat, and bared his teeth. He looked like a dragon guarding its gold.

Jake fell onto his backside in the dirt, his face pale as a sheet. He scrambled backward, crab-walking away from the demon horse.

“He… he defended you,” Jake stammered, his eyes wide.

I placed a hand on Brimstone’s flank. He was vibrating with rage, but he didn’t move. He held the line.

“Get out,” I said to Jake. “Before I let him loose.”

Jake didn’t need telling twice. He scrambled up and ran, forgetting his hat in the dirt.

I leaned my forehead against Brimstone’s neck, shaking so hard my teeth rattled. “Thank you,” I sobbed into his mane. “Thank you.”

News of the incident spread like wildfire. The “Devil Horse” had protected the bride. It was impossible. It was a miracle.

Reed didn’t say much when I told him, but I saw the dark look on his face when he looked at Jake during supper. He knew. He knew something had shifted. The power dynamic on the ranch was changing, and I was at the center of it.

But the real test came three days later.

It was a Sunday. The ranch was quiet. I walked Brimstone out of the corral.

No lead rope. I just walked, and he followed, his nose hovering near my shoulder. We walked past the barn, past the bunkhouse where the men watched in stunned silence, and out toward the open fields.

Reed was on the porch. He stood up slowly as we passed.

I didn’t stop until we reached the crest of the hill, overlooking the valley. The wind whipped my hair across my face. The world felt huge and wide and free.

I turned to Brimstone. “Are you ready?”

He stood steady as a rock.

I didn’t have a saddle. I grabbed a handful of his mane and swung myself up.

For a second, the world tilted. He shifted his weight, surprised by the burden. I held my breath. If he bucked now, I would die. It was that simple.

But he didn’t buck.

He gathered himself underneath me, a coiled spring of immense power. I squeezed my legs gently.

“Walk.”

And he walked.

We rode along the ridge, a silhouette against the vast Montana sky. I wasn’t controlling him; we were moving together. It was the most profound feeling of freedom I had ever known. For the first time in years, I wasn’t Emma the victim, or Emma the liar. I was just… me. Flying.

When we returned to the barn, the sun was setting. The men were gathered. They weren’t laughing anymore. They were staring with something like awe.

Reed was waiting at the gate. He opened it for us.

I slid off Brimstone’s back, my legs wobbly. I patted his neck, and he nudged my pocket, looking for the sugar cube I had started bringing him.

Reed looked at the horse, then at me. There was a strange light in his eyes. Respect? Or maybe something dangerous—hope.

“I’ve never seen anything like that,” he said quietly.

“He just needed to be asked, not told,” I replied, wiping sweat from my forehead.

“Maybe that’s true for people too,” Reed said.

The moment was fragile, beautiful. But like all fragile things, it was about to be shattered.

That night, I woke up to the smell of smoke.

Not the woodstove. This was acrid. Burning hay.

I sat up, heart pounding. The window! I looked out toward the barn.

Flames were licking up the side of the wooden structure. The orange glow lit up the night sky like a second, angry sun.

“Fire!” I screamed, tumbling out of bed. “Reed! Fire!”

I didn’t wait for him. I ran. barefoot, in my nightgown, out into the cold night.

Brimstone was in the corral next to the barn, not inside, thank God. But the smoke was drifting toward him, and the fire was terrifying him. He was screaming, throwing himself against the rails.

And the gate…

My blood froze. The gate to the corral was wide open.

But Brimstone wasn’t running out to safety. He was trapped by his own panic, confused by the smoke.

And then I saw why the gate was open.

A figure was sprinting away from the barn, disappearing into the darkness of the trees. It was a man’s silhouette. Limping slightly.

Jake.

He hadn’t just set the fire. He had opened the gate, hoping Brimstone would bolt into the wilderness and be lost forever. Or worse, run back into the burning barn in his confusion.

“Brimstone!” I screamed, running toward the inferno.

The heat hit me like a wall. The crackle of the flames was deafening. The other horses in the main stable were kicking their stalls, screaming in terror.

Reed burst out of the house, pulling on his boots. “The horses! Get the horses!” he yelled to the men pouring out of the bunkhouse.

But I only had eyes for one horse.

Brimstone had seen the open gate now. But instead of running to the fields, he was turning toward the fire, mesmerized and terrified, his instinct broken by the chaos.

“No!” I vaulted over the fence, ignoring the heat that singed my hair.

“Emma! Get back!” Reed roared from somewhere behind me.

I didn’t listen. I ran to Brimstone. He was rearing, striking at the smoke.

“Brimstone! Look at me!” I grabbed his halter—no, he didn’t wear one. I grabbed his mane. “Look at me!”

He rolled his eyes down to me. The fire reflected in them, a hellscape of orange and black.

“Trust me,” I choked out, the smoke filling my lungs. “We have to go. Now.”

I pulled. He resisted. He was frozen.

Then, a beam from the barn roof collapsed with a sound like a gunshot. Sparks showered over us. Brimstone shrieked.

I did the only thing I could think of. I jumped onto his back.

“Go!” I screamed, kicking his sides. “Run!”

This time, he listened. He didn’t run into the fire. He turned and bolted through the open gate, carrying me away from the flames, away from the ranch, and out into the pitch-black void of the prairie night.

We galloped until the glow of the fire was just a smudge on the horizon. We galloped until his breath came in ragged gasps and my legs were numb against his sides.

Finally, he slowed to a trot, then a walk. We were miles away. In the middle of nowhere.

I slid off him, my knees buckling. I hit the ground hard.

Silence surrounded us. The crickets were loud. The stars were indifferent.

I was safe from the fire. But I was alone, in the wilderness, with a horse that belonged to a man I was deceiving, and a foreman who had just tried to burn us all to the ground.

And I had no idea how to get back.

As I sat there in the dark, shivering in the cold night air, Brimstone lowered his head and nudged my shoulder. He stayed close.

But then, the sound of hoofbeats echoed in the distance. Fast. heavy.

Was it Reed coming to save me?

Or was it Jake, coming to finish the job?

I grabbed a rock from the ground, my hand trembling violently.

“Stay behind me,” I whispered to the horse.

The rider crested the hill, silhouetted against the moon. He pulled his horse up short.

“Emma?”

The voice was rough. Familiar. But it wasn’t Reed. And it wasn’t Jake.

It was a voice from my past. A voice I thought I had left buried in Missouri.

“Well, well,” the man said, striking a match to light a cigarette. The brief flare illuminated a face scarred by violence and a badge pinned to his chest. “Found you, little girl. You and your sister owe me a lot of money.”

My heart stopped beating. It wasn’t just Jake. The past hadn’t just hunted me down; it had caught up.

I looked at Brimstone. He was tired. I was defenseless.

“Run,” I whispered to the horse. “Go.”

But Brimstone didn’t run. He stepped in front of me, lowered his head, and let out a sound that was pure, primal warning.

The rising action had just turned into a war.

Part 3

The match flared, illuminating the man’s face—a roadmap of scars and bad intentions. He sat high on his horse, looking down at me like a wolf spotting a limping fawn. The badge on his chest caught the moonlight, but there was no law in his eyes, only greed.

“You’re a hard woman to track, Sarah,” he said, the smoke from his cigarette drifting toward me.

Sarah.

Hearing my real name out here, under the vast Montana sky, felt like a slap. The lie I had lived—the skin of “Emma”—peeled away, leaving me naked and shivering in the dirt.

“I don’t have the money, Vance,” I whispered, my voice trembling. “My father spent it all before he died. You know that.”

Vance chuckled, a dry, rattling sound. “Debts don’t die with fathers, darlin’. And neither do warrants. You stealing your dead sister’s identity? That’s fraud. You running off with the family savings? That’s theft.”

“It was twenty dollars!” I screamed, the desperation finally breaking through the fear. “It was twenty dollars to buy a train ticket so I wouldn’t starve!”

“It’s enough to hang you in Missouri,” Vance said coldly. He shifted in his saddle, reaching for the rope coiled at his horn. “Now, stand up. You’re coming with me.”

I scrambled backward, my hands scraping against the gravel. I looked at Brimstone. The great black stallion stood between us, his sides heaving from our escape, his coat slick with sweat and ash. He didn’t know about money or laws. He only knew threat.

And Vance smelled like a threat.

“Get out of the way, nag,” Vance spat, spurring his horse forward.

That was his mistake.

Brimstone didn’t flinch. He exploded.

With a scream that tore through the night, Brimstone reared. He looked ten feet tall, a monster of shadow and vengeance. He struck out with his front hooves, not at Vance, but at Vance’s horse.

Vance’s mount panicked, whinnying in terror and twisting violently. Vance lost his stirrup. He cursed, fumbling for the pistol at his hip.

“No!” I yelled.

Vance leveled the gun at Brimstone.

Bang.

The gunshot echoed across the plains, shattering the silence.

I screamed, covering my ears. I waited for Brimstone to fall. I waited for the heavy thud of his body.

But Brimstone was still standing.

It was Vance who groaned. His gun smoked in his hand, but his shot had gone wide as his horse bucked him off. He hit the ground with a sickening crunch.

Brimstone lunged. He wasn’t acting like a horse anymore; he was a predator protecting his pack. He pinned his ears and snapped his teeth inches from Vance’s face.

“Call him off!” Vance shrieked, scrambling backward in the dirt, his bravado gone. “Call him off, you witch!”

“Brimstone, stay!”

The voice didn’t come from me.

It came from the darkness behind us.

A rider emerged from the tree line, rifle rested easily against his shoulder. The moonlight caught the sharp angles of his face.

Reed Coulter.

He looked at the scene: the fallen detective, the terrified woman, and the “cursed” stallion standing guard like a sentinel from hell.

Reed didn’t look at me. He kept his eyes on Vance. “You’re trespassing, mister.”

Vance clutched his shoulder, grimacing. “I’m a deputized agent. I’m here for the girl. She’s a fugitive.”

Reed lowered the rifle slightly, his gaze finally shifting to me. I couldn’t breathe. This was the moment. The moment he found out everything.

“Is that true?” Reed asked. His voice was flat, unreadable.

I stood up, shaking, wiping the dust from my nightgown. I wanted to lie. I wanted to say Vance was crazy. But looking at Reed—this man who had fixed my shutters, who had defended me to his men—I couldn’t do it.

“My name is Sarah,” I whispered, tears spilling over. “Emma was my sister. She died two weeks before I came here. I… I had nowhere else to go.”

The silence that followed was heavier than the mountains.

Reed looked at me for a long time. I saw the hurt flash in his eyes—the betrayal. He didn’t like liars. He had told me that on day one.

“And the money?” Reed asked.

“Twenty dollars,” I choked out. “I took twenty dollars from my father’s stash after he passed out drunk. He would have drunk it away by morning. I used it for the train.”

Vance spat blood onto the grass. “She’s a thief. I’m taking her back.”

Reed cocked his rifle. The sound was crisp and final.

“You fired a weapon on my land,” Reed said to Vance. “You aimed at my horse. In Montana, that’s enough reason to leave you here for the coyotes.”

Vance froze.

“Get on your horse,” Reed ordered. “Ride North. If I see you again, I won’t miss.”

“You’re making a mistake, Coulter!” Vance yelled, dragging himself up. “She’s a liar! She’ll ruin you!”

“Go.”

Vance glared at me with pure venom, then limped to his horse. He mounted awkwardly, clutching his ribs, and disappeared into the dark.

I stood alone with Reed. And Brimstone.

I hugged my arms around myself, waiting for Reed to yell. Waiting for him to tell me to get out.

“Get on the horse,” Reed said quietly.

“Reed, I—”

“Get on the horse, Sarah.” He said the name with a strange weight, tasting the lie. “The barn is gone. The house is safe, but we have to go back.”

I mounted Brimstone. Reed didn’t offer to help. He turned his horse and started riding back toward the ranch. I followed, the distance between us feeling like an ocean.

The ride back was a funeral procession. The smell of smoke grew stronger the closer we got.

When we crested the final hill, the devastation hit me. The great barn, the heart of the ranch, was a smoldering skeleton of black beams and gray ash. The fire was out, thanks to the crew, but the damage was done.

Men were standing around, faces soot-stained and grim. And in the center of them, directing the cleanup like a general, was Jake.

Jake saw us coming. He saw me on Brimstone. His eyes narrowed.

“Boss!” Jake called out, walking over as we dismounted. “Thank God you’re back. We lost the barn, but we saved the house. I tried to stop the fire, but…” He glared at me. “It started near the girl’s stall. Probably knocked over a lantern in her sleep.”

He was blaming me. Of course.

I slid off Brimstone. My legs felt like jelly, but a cold rage was solidifying in my chest.

“You’re a liar,” I said. My voice was raspy from the smoke, but it carried.

The men stopped working.

Jake scoffed. “Excuse me?”

“You opened the gate,” I said, stepping toward him. “You set the fire to scare Brimstone out. You wanted him gone. You didn’t care if I burned with it.”

“She’s hysterical, Boss,” Jake said to Reed, shaking his head. “Shock. It does things to a woman’s mind.”

Reed stood between us, silent. He looked at the burned ruins. He looked at Jake. Then he looked at me.

“She’s not Emma,” Reed said suddenly.

The men muttered. Jake smirked. “I knew it. I knew she was trouble from the start.”

“Her name is Sarah,” Reed continued. “And she’s a fugitive.”

My heart shattered. He was turning me in. He was siding with Jake. I felt the tears start again, hot and hopeless.

“See?” Jake laughed, stepping forward. “I told you, Reed. She’s poison. We should run her off right now.”

Jake moved to grab my arm, emboldened by Reed’s words.

SCREECH.

Brimstone didn’t just warn this time. He moved like a striking snake.

He lunged past me and slammed his chest into Jake, knocking the foreman flat onto his back in the ash. Brimstone stood over him, one massive hoof raised, poised to crush Jake’s chest.

“Help! Shoot it!” Jake screamed, covering his face.

“Brimstone, down!” I yelled.

The horse froze, his hoof hovering inches from Jake’s ribs. He looked at me, waiting.

Reed walked over. He looked down at Jake, who was trembling in the dirt, terrified of the animal he had tried to kill.

“A horse doesn’t hate a person for no reason, Jake,” Reed said softly.

“He’s crazy! He’s a man-killer!” Jake sobbed.

“No,” Reed said. “He’s a judge.”

Reed reached into his pocket and pulled out something he had found in the dirt near the corral gate earlier—something I hadn’t seen him pick up.

It was a kerosene rag. And a lighter.

“Found these by the gate, Jake,” Reed said. “This lighter has your initials on it.”

The silence on the ranch was absolute.

Jake’s face went pale beneath the soot. “Reed, listen, I—”

“You burned my barn,” Reed said, his voice dropping to a terrifying whisper. “You endangered my stock. And you tried to kill this woman.”

“She’s a liar!” Jake shouted, pointing at me.

“She lied about her name,” Reed said. He looked at me then, and the ice in his eyes finally cracked. “But she didn’t lie about you. And she didn’t lie about him.” He nodded at Brimstone.

Reed turned back to Jake. “Get your things. You have ten minutes to be off my property. If you’re not, I let the horse finish what he started.”

Jake scrambled up, looking from Reed to the horse, then turned and ran toward the bunkhouse without a word.

The men watched him go. No one moved to help him.

Reed turned to me. The adrenaline was fading, leaving me dizzy.

“Go inside,” he said gently. “We have a lot to talk about.”

I nodded, clutching Brimstone’s mane for one last second of strength, then walked toward the house. The sun was beginning to rise, painting the sky in colors of bruise and blood.

Part 4

The kitchen was quiet. The kind of quiet that comes after a storm, where the air feels scrubbed clean but fragile.

I sat at the table, my hands wrapped around a mug of tea Reed had made. I hadn’t packed yet, but I knew I had to. My bag—the small, battered suitcase that had belonged to Emma—was by the door.

Reed stood at the window, watching the men clear the debris of the barn. He hadn’t spoken for twenty minutes.

“I’ll leave,” I said, breaking the silence. My voice sounded small in the large room. “I can catch the noon train. I won’t cause you any more trouble.”

Reed turned slowly. He looked tired. The lines around his eyes were deeper than before.

“Where will you go?” he asked.

“I don’t know,” I admitted. “West, maybe. California. Somewhere Vance won’t look.”

“He won’t look for you,” Reed said. “I wired the sheriff in Missouri this morning.”

My cup clattered against the saucer. “You… you turned me in?”

“I paid the debt,” Reed said simply. “And the interest. And a little extra to make sure the warrant was lost in a filing cabinet somewhere.”

I stared at him, my mouth open. “Reed… that was… I can’t pay you back.”

“I didn’t ask you to.”

He walked over to the table and pulled out the chair opposite me. He sat down, folding his large, rough hands on the wood.

“Why?” I asked. “I lied to you. I came here under false pretenses. I’m not the woman you wrote to.”

“No,” Reed said. “You’re not.”

He reached into his pocket and pulled out the original letter—the one Emma had written. He placed it on the table between us.

“Emma sounded nice,” Reed said. “Obedient. Quiet. Safe.”

He looked me in the eye.

“But safe doesn’t tame a stallion like Brimstone. Safe doesn’t ride bareback into a fire to save a creature everyone else gave up on. Safe doesn’t stand up to a man with a gun to protect a horse.”

I looked down at my hands. “I’m broken, Reed. Just like him. That’s the only reason I could do it. I know what it’s like to be afraid.”

“You’re not broken, Sarah,” Reed said. It was the first time he had used my real name with kindness. “You’re scarred. There’s a difference. Scars mean you survived.”

He pushed the letter aside.

“I don’t need a maid. I don’t need a cook. I can hire people for that.”

He reached across the table and took my hand. His skin was warm, calloused, and real.

“I need a partner,” he said. “Someone who understands that things—and people—aren’t disposable just because they’re difficult. This ranch… it’s lonely. It’s been lonely for a long time. But watching you with that horse… watching you fight for him…”

He paused, his voice catching slightly.

“I don’t want Emma. I want you.”

A tear slid down my cheek, hot and fast. “I come with a lot of baggage, Reed.”

“We’ve got plenty of room in the attic,” he smiled, a genuine, rare smile that transformed his face.

“Stay,” he whispered. “Not as a mail-order bride. Just stay. We’ll figure out the rest.”

I squeezed his hand back. “Okay.”

One Year Later

The sign over the new gate was simple. The Brimstone Sanctuary.

It wasn’t just a ranch anymore. The word had spread, carried on the wind and through the whispers of horse traders across three states. If you had a horse that was “ruined,” “crazy,” or “broken,” you didn’t shoot it. You sent it to Montana. You sent it to the woman who whispered to dragons.

I stood by the paddock fence, watching.

Brimstone was there. He was still black as night, still powerful, but the fire in his eyes was no longer fueled by terror. It was fueled by pride.

He was running alongside a new arrival—a terrified gray mare who had been beaten so badly she flinched at the wind. Brimstone wasn’t chasing her. He was shielding her. He trotted on her outside flank, placing his massive body between her and the fence, showing her the boundaries, showing her she was safe.

He was teaching her. Just as I had taught him.

“He’s a good foreman,” a voice said beside me.

I smiled and leaned back against Reed’s chest. He wrapped his arms around my waist, resting his chin on my shoulder.

“Better than the last one,” I joked.

Reed laughed, the sound vibrating through me. “Much better.”

Life hadn’t been perfect. We had hard winters. We had fights. We had moments where the trauma of my past crept in like a cold draft, waking me up screaming in the night. But Reed was always there. He didn’t try to fix me. He just held me until the shaking stopped.

He understood now. Some things aren’t broken to be fixed. They are broken to be understood. And once they are understood, they can heal themselves.

“We have a visitor,” Reed said, nodding toward the driveway.

A truck was pulling in. A young girl, no older than sixteen, hopped out. She looked terrified. She was clutching a bag that looked suspiciously like everything she owned. Behind her, in a trailer, a horse was kicking the metal walls, screaming in panic.

The girl looked at the sign. Then she looked at us. She saw the scars on my arms. She saw the way I stood—not perfect, but standing.

I opened the gate and walked out to meet her.

“I heard you can help him,” the girl stammered, pointing to the trailer. “They said he’s cursed.”

I looked at the trailer, then back at the girl. I saw the fear in her eyes—fear of the horse, but also fear of the world. I saw myself.

“There’s no such thing as a curse,” I said, extending my hand. “My name is Sarah. What’s yours?”

“Lily,” she whispered.

“Welcome home, Lily,” I said.

Behind me, Brimstone let out a loud, welcoming whinny.

The work wasn’t done. It never would be. There would always be broken things in the world. But as long as we had this land, this love, and this sky, we had a place to put them back together.

I looked back at Reed. He winked.

I wasn’t running anymore. I was exactly where I was supposed to be.

[THE END]